Back to the blog
recruiting tipsNovember 21, 20264 min read

One Semifinal, Three Different Box Scores: How to Make Sure the Stats Coaches See Are Actually Yours

On Friday night a major stats site listed the wrong team winning a City Section semifinal, and two outlets published different rushing totals for the same back. Here's where high school stats come from, who can fix them, and a five-minute weekly check every athlete should do before signing day.

WL

Will League

Founder's byline

One Semifinal, Three Different Box Scores: How to Make Sure the Stats Coaches See Are Actually Yours

Three things happened on one Friday night of the 2026 CIF playoffs:

  1. A wrong winner. Carson beat King/Drew 42-9 in the City Section Open Division semifinal, according to Damian Calhoun's final and the Los Angeles Times' Friday night score roundup. The LA Times' Eric Sondheimer then posted: "On Maxpreps, they have King/Drew winning over Carson 35-14. WRONG." By Saturday morning, at least one national score list was still printing Carson 35, King/Drew 14.

  2. Two rushing lines for one back. The LA Times credited Centennial's Malaki Davis with 120 yards on 16 carries in the Division 1 semifinal. MaxPreps' Performance of the Game post that night had 117 yards on 14 carries.

  3. A record-setter's total. In Wisconsin, MaxPreps had Kingston Allen at 306 yards in the state final. The state association (WIAA) had 308.

None of this is a scandal. It's what happens when stats get entered fast, by hand, on deadline. But if you're a senior with signing day on Dec. 2, the numbers on your page are your résumé, and you should know how they get there.

Where the stats come from

According to MaxPreps' own support pages:

  • Stats are entered by the head coach and coaching staff members with Team Admin access. Coaches request access, and MaxPreps says it reviews requests within 24 hours.

  • Teams can import stats from more than 80 stat partners (GameChanger and MaxStats among them) for most sports.

  • Scores mostly come from coaches and staff too. Fan-submitted scores go through a review process, and MaxPreps says it reviews corrections.

  • MaxPreps says it captured final scores for about 94% of varsity games nationwide in 2025-26 (about 99% in football). It also says plainly: "For official postseason results, the state athletic association is the final authority."

The two settings that quietly break a stat page

MaxPreps flags two coach-side issues worth knowing:

  • Season-to-date stats override game-by-game stats. If both are entered, the season totals win, and MaxPreps says that can keep athletes off the stat leaderboards.

  • Coaches can't delete a game that has stats attached. Only MaxPreps support can.

Your five-minute weekly check

  1. Open your page every Monday. Check last week's line against your film and the official box (if there is one).

  2. If something's wrong, tell your coach, not the internet. Only Team Admins can edit stats. Bring the timestamp from the film.

  3. Check the final score too. A wrong result on your team page follows you into every coach's search.

  4. Know which number to quote. When outlets disagree (306 vs. 308, 117 vs. 120), use the one your coach entered or the state association published. Don't use the bigger one.

  5. Keep your own log. A simple sheet with the date, opponent, your line and the film timestamp makes every profile and conversation easier.

Why it matters now

The early signing period opens Dec. 2. College staffs will pull your film and your numbers in the next 11 days. A missing playoff game or a mis-credited touchdown isn't fatal, but it's one more question you'd rather not be answering.

Keep your verified stats, film and offers in one profile coaches can trust: Request Your Invite.

Sources

Reporting compiled Saturday, Nov. 21, 2026, about 5:50-6:30 a.m. Pacific Time.

  1. Damian Calhoun (@DamianCalhoun), X, Nov. 20, 9:52 p.m. PT: "Carson 42, King Drew 9." https://x.com/DamianCalhoun/status/2124018097241886978

  2. Los Angeles Times staff, "High school football: Friday’s semifinal playoff scores," Nov. 20, 2026, 11:48 p.m. PT: "#1 Carson 42, #5 King/Drew 9." https://www.latimes.com/sports/highschool/story/2026-11-20/high-school-football-fridays-semifinal-playoff-scores

  3. Eric Sondheimer (@latsondheimer), X, Nov. 20, 10:06 p.m. PT: "On Maxpreps, they have King/Drew winning over Carson 35-14. WRONG." https://x.com/latsondheimer/status/2124021506229535055

  4. High School On SI semifinal score list (still showing "Carson 35, King/Drew 14" when fetched Saturday morning). https://www.si.com/high-school/california/cif-southern-section-la-city-section-football-semifinal-scores-all-divisions-01m7y5e9mj23

  5. Eric Sondheimer, Los Angeles Times, Centennial-Sierra Canyon recap, Nov. 20, 2026: Davis 120 yards on 16 carries. https://www.latimes.com/sports/highschool/story/2026-11-20/sierra-canyon-corona-centennial-football-semifinal-playoff-game-recap

  6. MaxPreps (@MaxPreps), X, Nov. 20, 9:45 p.m. PT: "Malaki Davis earns Performance of the Game honors after rushing for 117 yards and two touchdowns on 14 carries." https://x.com/MaxPreps/status/2124016218440933883

  7. MaxPreps, Kingston Allen state-final story (306 yards), Nov. 20, 2026. https://www.maxpreps.com/news/K8cm9RZ67EeucCPu9QG1Lw/high-school-football-kingston-allen-runs-for-306-yards-to-lead-team-to-wisconsin-state-title%2C-ties-national-record-with-71st-rushing-touchdown-of-the-season.htm; WIAA recap (308 yards). https://www.wiaawi.org/about-wiaa/news/allen-leads-notre-dame-division-2-football-state-title

  8. MaxPreps Support, "Stats FAQs" (updated Oct. 22, 2026): coach and staff entry, the 24-hour access review, season-to-date override and leaderboards, 80+ import partners, and no deleting games with stats. https://support.maxpreps.com/hc/en-us/articles/4404593358107-Stats-FAQs

  9. MaxPreps Support, "How accurate are scores reported on MaxPreps?" (July 2026): coach entry, the fan-report review, the GameChanger and MaxStats partners, corrections, 94%/99% coverage, and the state association as final authority. https://support.maxpreps.com/hc/en-us/articles/53680606871451-How-accurate-are-scores-reported-on-MaxPreps

  10. Early signing period opens Dec. 2: Aggies Wire, Nov. 20, 2026 (Dec. 2-4). https://aggieswire.usatoday.com/story/sports/college/aggies/recruiting/2026/11/20/texas-aggies-football-recruiting-sayquan-snell-officially-visit-texas/92881997007/